Scott Hatley
Type: Person
As of November 2026, Scott Hatley has been mentioned in one podcast episode on MrBallen (Jan 2026). Identified via FBI fingerprint database match as the killer; Cindy Hallmark's younger cousin and member of Susan's friend group; later confesses in diary.
Identified via FBI fingerprint database match as the killer; Cindy Hallmark's younger cousin and member of Susan's friend group; later confesses in diary.
| Mentioned in | 1 episode on 1 podcast (as of November 2026) |
|---|---|
| First heard | Jan 2026 on MrBallen |
| Role | Convicted murderer (plea deal) |
| Affiliation | Round table friend group (informal) |
Who talks about Scott Hatley on podcasts?
MrBallen brought up Scott Hatley; the most recent mention was Jan 2026 on MrBallen.
- She had a second chance at life, but the DEVIL had other plans... on MrBallen (Jan 2026) — MrBallen
What is Scott Hatley mentioned alongside?
Scott Hatley is most often mentioned alongside Cindy Hallmark, Susan Woods and Lieutenant Ken Maltby.
Affiliated with: Cindy Hallmark, Susan Woods
Mentioned together: Lieutenant Ken Maltby, Dungeons and Dragons, Indianapolis, Susan Woods, Cindy Hallmark, Fort Worth, Roy Hayes, Michael Woods, Stevenville, Joe Atkins