The monster planned to murder his entire family, and the Vincent Brothers case terrified everyone

What this episode is about

The Vincent Brothers case centers around the shocking murder of his wife, children, and mother-in-law in Bakersfield, California, on July 8, 2003, leading police to investigate motives beyond robbery. Despite Vincent's alibi clearing him of direct involvement, the case revealed a disturbing pattern of his tumultuous personal life, marked by allegations of domestic abuse and misconduct, ultimately frightening the entire community.

Key takeaways

• Vincent's stellar reputation masked a history of domestic turmoil, proving that appearances can be dangerously deceiving.
• In a chilling reminder of trust, Vincent's notoriety thwarted police action against harassment claims; power can silence victims.
• Three months before tragedy, Vincent's exit hinted at unresolved conflicts, suggesting a powder keg waiting for a spark.
• The family that volunteered together was shattered in silence; community ties don't always protect against domestic horrors.
• This case illustrates that a respected position can distort moral accountability—public personas may hide profound personal flaws.

Who speaks in this episode?

• Vincent Brothers
• Joanie Harper
• Kelsey Span
• Detective Watts
• Lisa Green
• Dr. Lyn Kimsey
• Carla Tafoya

What is discussed, and when

1. 0:00 – 3:00: Bakersfield, California State University, Vincent Brothers
2. 3:00 – 6:00: Ernestine Harper, Bakersfield, John C Fremont Elementary School, Black Angus
3. 6:00 – 9:00: Bakersfield, Kelsey Span, Vincent Brothers
4. 9:00 – 12:00: Vincent Brothers, Bakersfield, Dr. Lyn Kimsey, Dodge Neon
5. 12:00 – 15:00: Dr. Lyn Kimsey, Dodge Neon, Lisa Green
6. 15:00 – 18:00: Vincent Brothers, San Quentin State Prison

Notable quotes from "The monster planned to murder his entire family, and the Vincent Brothers case terrified everyone"

• As a school administrator his two brief previous marriages had ended in separation in 1988 during his tenure at California State University in Bakersfield he had his first…

  about California State University · at 1:18

• Record the school administration transferred him to another school following their inquiry Vincent started working at John C Fremont Elementary School in Bakersfield California…

  about Bakersfield · at 3:06

• The house in April 3 months preceding the Dreadful incident due to the frequent conflicts he had with his mother-in-law Ernestine on Sunday July 6th 2003 Joanie a accompanied…

  about Ernestine Harper · at 4:47

• Covered the bodies in the bedroom with blankets and pillows taken from other rooms on July 8th 2003 Joan's closest friend Kelsey span grew concerned as she hadn't heard from…

  about Kelsey Span · at 6:47

• Efforts authorities lack a direct evidence linking Vincent to the murders Vincent Brothers had hired a Dodge Neon upon his arrival in Columbus Ohio and stayed at his brother's…

  about Dodge Neon · at 10:06

• Kimsey an expert in bug identification mtic ully analyzing insects found in the car Dr kimsey's examination unveiled over a 100 insects meticulously identified by species…

  about Dr. Lyn Kimsey · at 10:55

• The trial commenced in 2007 with prosecutor Lisa green leading the case the prosecution posited a theory attributing the motive for the murders to financial motives contending…

  about Lisa Green · at 12:04

• On September 27 2007 judge Michael Bush of the dur County Superior Court sentenced Vincent Brothers to death by lethal injection and was detained at San Quenton State Prison in…

  about Vincent Brothers · at 16:14

Who and what is mentioned in this episode?

People

• Vincent Brothers — Person · Primary subject (perpetrator/defendant in case narrative) · 6 mentions · first at 0:48
  The episode centers on the murders of his family and the investigation/trial that led to his conviction and death sentence.
• Dr. Lyn Kimsey — Person · Referenced expert witness (entomology/forensics) · 2 mentions · first at 10:53
  Presented as an insect-identification expert whose analysis of bugs in the rental car supports the prosecution’s travel/timeline theory.
• Ernestine Harper — Person · Victim (mother-in-law) / contextual character · 3 mentions · first at 4:12
  Joanie’s mother and a murder victim; also described as a civil-rights advocate and a source of conflict with Vincent.
• Kelsey Span — Person · Discovering witness / reporting witness · 2 mentions · first at 6:50
  Joanie’s close friend who performs the welfare check, discovers the bodies, and calls authorities—triggering the official investigation response.
• Lisa Green — Person · Prosecutor (trial lead) · 1 mention · first at 12:04
  Named as the prosecutor leading the 2007 trial and presenting the state’s motive and evidence theory.

Products & tech

• Dodge Neon — Product · Evidence · 2 mentions · first at 10:11
  Key piece of evidence linking Vincent Brothers to the crime scene.

Places & events

• Bakersfield — Place · Setting · 7 mentions · first at 0:07
  Primary location where the tragic events of the case occurred.
• John C Fremont Elementary School — Place · Workplace · 1 mention · first at 3:07
  School where Vincent Brothers worked and became a popular figure.
  School in Bakersfield California where he became a popular and well-regarded presence his notable routine involved ensuring the safe passage of students by walking them home…
• California State University — Place · Educational Institution · 2 mentions · first at 1:22
  University where Vincent Brothers pursued further education.
• San Quentin State Prison — Place · Prison · 1 mention · first at 16:25
  Current location where Vincent Brothers is detained.
  On September 27 2007 judge Michael Bush of the dur County Superior Court sentenced Vincent Brothers to death by lethal injection and was detained at San Quenton State Prison in…
• University of California Davis — Place · Educational Institution · 1 mention · first at 10:51
  University involved in the forensic analysis of the case.
  Enforcement meticulously examined the Dodge focusing on its radiator and air filters the bohart Museum of Entomology at the University of California Davis was enlisted For…
• Black Angus — Place · Restaurant · 1 mention · first at 5:11
  Place where the family had lunch before the tragic events.
  Attended a morning church service it marked Marshall's inaugural attendance at the church following the service they went for lunch at the Black Angus before heading back home…

Full transcript with timestamps

0:04 incent Brothers a well-loved principal in Bakersfield California received news that on Tuesday July 8th 2003 his wife children and mother-in-law were found murdered in their home despite the house being turned over and left in a mess nothing had been stolen and therefore police ruled out robbery suspecting a deliberate Act of homicide Vincent had been cleared due to his absence at he wasn't even in town and had provided a solid Alibi to prove so however on further investigations detectives une earthed a chilling truth that left the entire community in shock this is the Sinister case of Vincent Brothers Vincent Brothers was born on May 30th 1962 in bport Long Island in New York described as charismatic dependable and diligent from a young age Vincent had also dedicated time to serve in the Marine reserves following his graduation from norfol State University he ventured West in the mid 8s to pursue

1:08 further education ultimately obtaining his master's degree in California Vincent's past was marked by tumultuous relationships despite swiftly ascending as a school administrator his two brief previous marriages had ended in separation in 1988 during his tenure at California State University in Bakersfield he had his first child daughter with his then girlfriend to establish paternity Vincent filed a lawsuit against her and ultimately gained custody and visitation rights after verification initially ordered to pay $350 monthly for support this amount was raised to $771 by 2003 that same year he faced legal consequences receiving a Six-Day jail sentence and probation for a misdemeanor charge of spousal abuse in 1992 Vincent entered another marriage which also ended abruptly due to allegations of threats to kill and physical abuse by his second wife leading to her filing for divorce in 1996 allegations surfaced regarding

2:11 Vincent's sexual misconduct towards a colleague at Emerson Middle School where he served as the vice principal the woman reported instances of harassment stating that during a visit to his residence Vincent had physically assaulted her and prevented her from contacting the authorities by seizing the phone she attempted to report the in to the police but claimed she was dissuaded from doing so by them because Vincent was regarded as a respected member of the community implying that her report might not be taken seriously or acted upon due to his standing the harassment continued including inappropriate touching at the school's front counter leading the woman to take a leave of absence from what she deemed a harsh work environment as the intimidation escalated to threatening phone calls the school district investigated the claims cautioning Vince vent about potential career Jeopardy have proven true while Vincent denied

3:03 the accusations and had no disciplinary record the school administration transferred him to another school following their inquiry Vincent started working at John C Fremont Elementary School in Bakersfield California where he became a popular and well-regarded presence his notable routine involved ensuring the safe passage of students by walking them home after school hours during his tenure at Fremont Elementary Vincent crossed paths with Joe Harper who served as the campus security supervisor and also recognized for her role as a basketball official they started dating and their marriage ensued following the arrival of their first child Marcus and their family expanded with the birth of their second child Lindsay in 2000 however due to Vincent's infidelity their marriage was annulled in September 2001 in 2003 Vincent and Joanie secretly remarried and four months later their third-born child

3:58 Marshall was born but it wasn't long before Joanie confided in friends that their marriage was once again facing issues this time however she expressed fear that Vincent might try to get rid of her Joanie the loving mother of three resided with her husband her mother Ernestine Harper and children in Bakersfield California known within their Community as a joyful and involved family they actively engaged in community events and maintained amicable connections with others as mentioned earlier Joanie Pro ued her passion as a basketball official while her mother garnered recognition for aiding wrongly accused minorities as a civil rights Advocate Outsiders perceived Vincent and Joan's marriage as solid oblivious to any signs of the tragic events that would unfold later Vincent had already moved out of the house in April 3 months preceding the Dreadful incident due to the frequent conflicts he had with his

4:53 mother-in-law Ernestine on Sunday July 6th 2003 Joanie a accompanied by her three children Marcus Lindsay and six-week-old Marshall and hernes Harper attended a morning church service it marked Marshall's inaugural attendance at the church following the service they went for lunch at the Black Angus before heading back home once home as was their routine they lay down for a nap before planning to attend the evening church service in a harrowing sequence of events Joanie and her children were in one bedroom while her mother occupied another area of the house when they were ruthlessly and fatally attacked strikingly there were no apparent signs of forced entry the as salent breached the house and initiated the assault by firing two shots at Jan's head in her bedroom followed by targeting Lindsay in the center of her back Ernestine likely alerted by the noise moved towards the hallway to investigate she was armed

5:48 with a 38 revolver but tragically she never even had the opportunity to defend herself the as salent fatally shot her twice in the face leaving her collapsed in the hallway just outside her bedroom returning to Jan's room the attacker proceeded to shoot Marcus and delivered a final fatal shot to the baby's back each gunshot was strategically aimed to ensure fatal harm the as salant rather than immediately fleeing proceeded to the kitchen retrieving a knife from the Butcher Block returning to the bedroom they viciously stabbed Joanie multiple times in the back the as salant then tampered with the TV connections but placed the TV carefully on the ground additionally Joan's purse was emptied onto the laundry room floor yet nothing valuable was taken including money that was left untouched it appeared the as salent aimed to mislead the authorities creating the impression of a break-in and seeking to eliminate any potential

6:44 Witnesses afterward the as salant covered the bodies in the bedroom with blankets and pillows taken from other rooms on July 8th 2003 Joan's closest friend Kelsey span grew concerned as she hadn't heard from Joanie her mother or the children since they attended church that Sunday worried that something might have happened Kelsey decided to visit Joan's home to check on them using the key Joanie had entrusted to her Kelsey attempted to unlock the side door but found it hard to do so as something was preventing it from opening she proceeded to the back of the house and discovered an unlocked sliding glass door which was an unusual occurrence upon entering she made the grizzly discovery of Joanie Ernestine Marcus Lindsay and Marshall all deceased acting swiftly Kelsey contacted the authorities at 7:00 a.m. prompting their arrival to the horrifying scene where the five individuals had been brutally

7:38 murdered the peaceful ranch style residents where Joanie her children and mother resided sat in a tranquil corner lot within the neighborhood law enforcement concluded that the family was tragically killed on a Sunday afternoon following their return from church detectives assess the situation identifying Joanie as the primary target due to the severity of her injuries they inferred that the as salant actions indicated profound anger police expressed concern for Vincent's safety and discovered he had traveled to Ohio one of the detectives detective Watts traveled to North Carolina as Vincent and his brother Melvin had gone there to visit their mother upon interacting with Vincent North Carolina police found him in a traumatized State deeply distressed and unable to articulate coherent sentences which didn't offer much insight into the investigation his demeanor didn't align with that of a

8:32 probable killer moreover considering he was on the opposite side of the country at the time of the murders they initially excluded him as a suspect additionally Vincent provided receipts confirming purchases made on the days surrounding the tragedy solidifying his absence from Bakersfield California where the horrific events unfolded however detective Watts still harbored doubts he observed that Vincent never asked how his wife and children died di on July 11th 2003 Vincent Brothers returned to Los Angeles notably absent from his family's memorial service however on July 16th 2003 he attended their funeral the police delve deeper into the investigation they discovered that Vincent had moved out from his family's residence in April 2003 and was no longer living with them his wife Joanie had been planning a second divorce and intended to pursue child support for their children authorities also Unearthed Vincent's

9:31 history of violence against women prompting a closer examination of his Alibi further scrutiny revealed surveillance videos from store checkouts depicting Melvin not Vincent making purchases confronted with this evidence Melvin disclosed that Vincent instructed him to visit various stores at specific times using Vincent's name instead of his own police could not locate any Witnesses who had seen Vincent during the tragic period according to Melvin and the family they had not encountered Vincent from the evening of July 4th to the evening of July 7th despite their efforts authorities lack a direct evidence linking Vincent to the murders Vincent Brothers had hired a Dodge Neon upon his arrival in Columbus Ohio and stayed at his brother's house according to police speculations Vincent purportedly flew to Columbus on July 2 2003 under the pretense to visit family on July 4th he eled allegedly journeyed

10:30 back from Ohio to Bakersfield where the tragic incident occurred on the Sunday afternoon July 6th 2003 afterward he returned to Ohio arriving late on Monday the 7th law enforcement meticulously examined the Dodge focusing on its radiator and air filters the bohart Museum of Entomology at the University of California Davis was enlisted For assistance with Dr ly kimsey an expert in bug identification mtic ully analyzing insects found in the car Dr kimsey's examination unveiled over a 100 insects meticulously identified by species notably some exclusive to the western region beyond the Rockies certain insects indicated Vincent traveled at night through careful analysis she charted a path indicating the car's Westward Journey from Ohio investigators Tracked Down the vehicle's previous five renters confirming none had driven the car to California or near the Rockies in their scrutiny of evidence from the home

11:32 police focused on photographic evidence and observed a latex glove tip among items discarded in the laundry room upon testing the tip revealed a DNA match identifying it as a 1 in6 billion match to Vincent Brothers detective Watts had discovered that Vincent intended to depart town and noticed he had started to sell his possessions and had even listed his house for sale consequently on April 30th 2004 Vincent faced arrest and was charged with five counts of first-degree murder the trial commenced in 2007 with prosecutor Lisa green leading the case the prosecution posited a theory attributing the motive for the murders to financial motives contending that Vincent acted out due to Jan's impending divorce fearing potential child support payments they portrayed Vincent as a serial adulterer who would disappear for long periods of time often responding violently when questioned upon resurfacing particularly towards whoever

12:32 his wife or girlfriend was at the time numerous Witnesses including Dr Lyn kimy were summoned by the prosecution kimsey attested that the insects discovered in the Dodge Neon aligned with those typically found along Interstate 70 while traveling testimony further corroborated that the 5,424 Mi driven from July 2nd to July 11th aligned with the presented evidence however when Melvin testified he attempted to alter his previous statements claiming that he had lied to the police regarding Vincent providing him with a credit card to use the defense countered by presenting an expert in high-speed driving asserting the difficulty of maintaining an average speed of 70 mph throughout the journey from Ohio to California they contended that such a trip would have been impossible for Vincent to accomplish additionally their own Pathologists took the stand testifying that the murders likely occurred as late as Monday morning on

13:29 July 7th 2003 to support their case the defense introduced interrogation tapes aiming to demonstrate that Melvin had been coerced by the police into altering his testimony they also brought forth a witness to a car incident that Vincent claimed took place on Sunday morning where a boy on a bicycle collided with Vincent's rental car at an intersection while this incident wasn't reported to the police due to no damages or injuries the prosecution diligently sought to verify the bike accident story detective Watts traveled back to Ohio and located Tamba lebby a car dealer who flew to California to testify lebby confirmed that he was driving during the bike accident and that the boy collided with his car while he was stationary at an intersection the defense strategy involved presenting Vincent's other brother Troy as Vincent's Alibi witness Troy was intended to testify that he had flown in from New York and spent that

14:24 Saturday and Sunday with Vincent touring different state colleges in Ohio Vincent expressed interest in applying to these colleges to further his Graduate Studies however complications arose when after lunch on the day Troy was scheduled to testify he was nowhere to be seen consequently Vincent himself took the stand vehemently denying any extramarital Affairs and adamantly refuting the accusation of murdering his family throughout his testimony Vincent frequently broke down in tears the prosecution brought in Franklin School principal Carla tooya as a witness she testified about her involvement with Vincent dating back to the year his son was born in 1996 and their on and off relationship until 2002 when she ended it Tafoya then confessed that she and Vincent had been intimate just weeks before the family tragedy contradicting Vincent's staunch denial of previous Affairs this Revelation undermined

15:21 Vincent's claims of fidelity the prosecution posited that the crime had been meticulously premeditated acquiring knowledge of the family's Sunday routine granted the killer control and a window of opportunity exploiting this familiarity the perpetrator waited until the family was asleep using a copied key to gain entry through the sliding glass door and methodically execute each member of the family on May 15th 2007 Vincent received a guilty verdict on five counts of first-degree murder with particular circumstances that made him liable for the death penalty the jury after hearing test testimony from 137 Witnesses deliberated for just under 2 days before reaching their decision following the verdict Vincent was escorted out of the courtroom and returned to lero Detention Facility under strict security measures on September 27 2007 judge Michael Bush of the dur County Superior Court sentenced Vincent Brothers to death by

16:22 lethal injection and was detained at San Quenton State Prison in California where he is still currently housed during the sentencing hearing family members were granted the opportunity to deliver statements among them an emotionally charged declaration from his only surviving child his firstborn Margaret Kern Brothers Margaret announced her resignation from the brother's family expressing that upon leaving the courtroom she would solely identify herself as Margaret Kern she went on to State I am leaving my name with him I don't have a father now he is just a man hand off to a chair looking straight ahead he will never see me again until it's time to die Vincent Brothers lacked empathy and remorse for his actions a common trait in what many call a psychopath his perception of his children as mere objects suggested a complete Detachment from any emotional connection with them the act of stabbing Joanie appeared to

17:22 be a deliberate means of severing his ties with her on a physical level his action of covering the victims seemed to indicate an attempt to Shield himself from confronting the aftermath of his deeds suggesting a deeply personal involvement in these killings it is sad and unfortunate what all the victims faced against this monster as we reflect on this heart-wrenching tale our thoughts are with the victims whose lives were tragically cut short and the loved ones they left behind if you found this video compelling be sure to like And subscribe to our Channel and check out our other videos thank you for watching

Questions about this episode

Who speaks in "The monster planned to murder his entire family, and the Vincent Brothers case terrified everyone"?

Vincent Brothers, Joanie Harper, Kelsey Span, Detective Watts, Lisa Green, Dr. Lyn Kimsey, Carla Tafoya.

What is "The monster planned to murder his entire family, and the Vincent Brothers case terrified everyone" about?

The Vincent Brothers case centers around the shocking murder of his wife, children, and mother-in-law in Bakersfield, California, on July 8, 2003, leading police to investigate motives beyond robbery. Despite Vincent's alibi clearing him of direct involvement, the case revealed a disturbing pattern of his tumultuous personal life, marked by allegations of domestic abuse and misconduct,…

What is mentioned in this Casefile True Crime episode?

12 people, works and ideas are mentioned, including Vincent Brothers, Bakersfield, Dr. Lyn Kimsey, Ernestine Harper, Kelsey Span, Dodge Neon. Each one on this page links to its own page with every episode that mentions it.

How long is "The monster planned to murder his entire family, and the Vincent Brothers case terrified everyone"?

The episode runs 18 min; the transcript is about 2,765 words in 19 timestamped sections.

More from Casefile True Crime

• All analyzed episodes
• Books mentioned on Casefile True Crime
• People mentioned on Casefile True Crime
• Topics mentioned on Casefile True Crime