Transcript

New Savannah Guthrie Video Reveals Nancy Was "Taken From Her Bed" and Ups Reward to $1 Million

From Megyn Kelly · Episode page · Watch on YouTube

· 16 min · 3,166 words · 33 timestamped sections

This is the full, timestamped transcript of "New Savannah Guthrie Video Reveals Nancy Was "Taken From Her Bed" and Ups Reward to $1 Million", an episode of Megyn Kelly published February 24, 2026 (16 min, about 3,166 words). It mentions 18 people, works and ideas, including Nancy Guthrie, Savannah Guthrie, Abduction, reward, Kidnapping.

What this episode is about

A discussion of Savannah Guthrie’s recent statement claiming Nancy Guthrie was “taken from her bed” in the dark, its potential implications for the case, and how this detail aligns with or contradict earlier reports about possible entry points and the investigation. It also notes speculation about whether the phrase reflects literal kidnapping from bed versus a figurative phrasing used in the coverage.

Key takeaways

  • Savannah’s line about 'taken from her bed' reframes the scene from door-knock speculation to a genuine, potentially force-entry narrative shift.
  • The shift from hopeful to despondent within the family signals a tacit timeline collapse and raises urgency for corroborating evidence.
  • Abduction vs ransom: media emphasis on timing hints at law-enforcement constraints, not just sensationalism, shaping public perception.
  • Nesting details—back door open, possible own-door entry—complicate alibis; every minor fact forces a reweighing of suspects.
  • Savannah’s statements may reflect information leaks shaping narrative, illustrating how familial disclosures influence investigative priorities.

Who speaks in this episode?

What is discussed, and when

  1. – 3:00: Savannah Guthrie, Nancy Guthrie, Tomaso, Annie Duke
  2. – 6:00: Abduction, Nancy Guthrie, Kidnapping, hope
  3. – 9:00: Aurora James, reward, urgency, Nancy Guthrie
  4. – 12:00: urgency, reward, Nancy Guthrie, Savannah Guthrie
  5. – 15:00: Abduction, Kidnapping, reward, Annie Duke
  6. – 16:26: Birch Gold Group

Notable quotes from "New Savannah Guthrie Video Reveals Nancy Was "Taken From Her Bed" and Ups Reward to $1 Million"

  • Actually to go through today. That statement plus there's a couple of other pieces, as I mentioned, something's just breaking about the DNA. what jumped out at me was I don't…
    about DNA · at
  • Other people have speculated he rang the doorbell to get Nancy Guthrie to come downstairs because there didn't appear to be forced entry at least at the front. Ashley Banfield reported early on in this case that her source.
    about Nancy Guthrie · at
  • That Savannah believes her mom did in fact return home to her house after having dinner with Tomaso and Annie, Savannah's sister and brother-in-law earlier in the evening.…
    about Tomaso · at
  • Dispose of the hostage. So I think regrettably, this was an abduction. If it wasn't for kidnapping, what was the motivation? What was the reasoning behind that?
    about Abduction · at
  • Saying it's an abduction and that they don't know. And the scary thing here is I think eventually that the FBI does catch this individual. it's just an odds game, with enough…
    about FBI · at
  • And I know we talked about this I think two weeks ago when I was with you and the you know the reward was 50 grand and I was you said it need to be higher.
    about reward · at
  • Or looking for clues, but they were looking. But who ends the search and rescue after 24 hours?
    about Aurora James · at
  • Because kidnappers actually want to make money. They don't send a note and then never respond to you and give you no avenue to negotiate with them. And here finally, they're…
    about Kidnapping · at

Who and what is mentioned in this episode?

People

  • Nancy Guthrie — Person · Victim / central missing person in the case · 5 mentions · first at
    The episode centers on the circumstances of her disappearance (abduction vs kidnapping), evidence (entry, blood trail, pacemaker timing), and efforts to locate her.
  • Savannah Guthrie — Person · Referenced family member / key source of new information · 4 mentions · first at
    Her public statement is treated as breaking news because it implies Nancy Guthrie was taken from her bed and signals the family's shifting hope and reward strategy.
    Intended to or not, but she made a little news about the actual crime where she said, It's day 24 since our mom was taken in the dark of night from her bed.
  • Aurora James — Person · Panelist / commentator · 3 mentions · first at
    He emphasizes urgency failures (search called off, reward too low) and interprets Savannah Guthrie's language as signaling likely death and a shift in strategy.
  • Tomaso — Person · Referenced suspect-adjacent figure (brother-in-law) / last-known-contact context · 2 mentions · first at
    He is described as having dinner with Nancy Guthrie and allegedly dropping her off; the panel discusses suspicion and whether mentions are meant to 'rehabilitate' him.
  • Annie Duke — Person · Referenced family member (sister) / suspicion discourse · 2 mentions · first at
    She is cited as Savannah Guthrie's sister and is discussed in the context of public focus/suspicion and Savannah's perceived endorsement of her.
    That Savannah believes her mom did in fact return home to her house after having dinner with Tomaso and Annie, Savannah's sister and brother-in-law earlier in the evening.…
  • Tim and Eric — Person · Panelist / commentator · 1 mention · first at
    He provides analysis supporting the abduction framing, comments on family hope, and discusses investigative dynamics (tips, ransom note behavior).
  • Ashley Banfield — Person · Referenced journalist / source of early reporting · 1 mention · first at
    She is cited as having reported forced entry and an open back door via a source, shaping theories about how the intruder entered.
    Downstairs because there didn't appear to be forced entry at least at the front. Ashley Banfield reported early on in this case that her source told her there was forced entry.…
  • Ian Santos Ruiz — Person · Referenced reporter / attribution for reward-timing explanation · 1 mention · first at
    He is cited for reporting that the family wanted a larger reward on day one but was advised by law enforcement to delay to avoid overwhelming tip infrastructure.
    That well and there are reports now today that she was reportedly ready. Michael Ruiz of Fox reporting on X. Sources with knowledge of the family's thinking say the Guthri initially raised the idea of the reward, this bigger reward on the.
  • Megan Ramsay — Person · Referenced comparison case (bed abduction trope) · 1 mention · first at
    Mentioned as an analogy for 'taken from her bed' language; used to question whether Savannah's phrasing was literal or rhetorical.
    Is she just saying that as if to say, sometimes in kidnappings, like a John Manet Ramsay taken, from her bed type of deal. And it's almost like something you would say. But I'm with you. I think she was literally that Savannah knows.

Companies & orgs

  • FBI — Organization · Investigative agency referenced · 2 mentions · first at
    Discussed as deploying resources and as the agency likely to eventually catch the perpetrator, framing the investigation's scale and capability.
  • TMZ — Organization · Media outlet referenced in ransom-note discussion · 1 mention · first at
    Mentioned as the recipient of a purported ransom note, used to argue about whether the crime fits kidnapping behavior.
    The sheriff initially thinking this is easily a kidnapping because he saw a ransom note come in to TMZ, which might be why he releases the crime scene way too early and then…

Concepts & topics

  • Abduction — Concept · Core topic / investigative framing · 8 mentions · first at
    Panelists repeatedly argue the facts fit an abduction rather than a profit-motivated kidnapping, affecting expectations about communication, survival odds, and investigative urgency.
  • reward — Concept · Core topic / investigative lever · 6 mentions · first at
    The reward amount (from $50k to $1M) is used as a proxy for urgency, strategy, and law-enforcement advice about managing tips and infrastructure.
  • Kidnapping — Concept · Contrasting hypothesis / debated classification · 4 mentions · first at
    The discussion contrasts kidnapping (ransom/negotiation) with abduction (no contact, possible panic/violence), using the lack of negotiation as a key indicator.
  • urgency — Concept · Investigative critique / performance metric · 5 mentions · first at
    Speakers argue the case has been handled without appropriate urgency, citing the low initial reward and early termination of search and rescue.
    Money talks and for me it speaks to what I felt the whole time just the lack of urgency in this case. 24 days, it feels like we're working this like it's a, a robbery or burglary. It just has never felt to me.
  • hope — Concept · Emotional theme / family messaging · 3 mentions · first at
    Hope is discussed as both a family coping mechanism and a signal of changing expectations, with Savannah's statement interpreted as increasingly despondent.
    Now one thing that I take from Savannah's newest video is that the there's more despondency and less hope in the family. she certainly is starting to come around to the fact…
  • DNA — Concept · Emerging evidence topic · 1 mention · first at
    Referenced as 'just breaking' information, implying new forensic developments relevant to identifying the perpetrator.

Sponsors

  • Birch Gold Group — Company · Advertiser / sponsor · 3 mentions · first at
    Appears in a mid-episode ad read promoting gold/precious metals diversification and IRA/401k conversion services.
    Impact the US economy. See if holding gold in a tax sheltered retirement account is right for you. Burge Gold can help you convert an existing IRA or 401k into an IRA in gold.…

Full transcript with timestamps

I wanted to talk about the uh Savannah Guthrie latest statement. There's a lot actually to go through today. That statement plus there's a couple of other pieces, as I mentioned, something's just breaking about the DNA. Um what jumped out at me was I don't know if she intended to or not, but she made a little news about the actual crime where she said, "It's day 24 since our mom was taken in the dark of night from her bed."

Yep. No one has ever said that before. In fact, the sheriff said it early on and then took it back and said, "I didn't mean to say that. I'm I'm not confirming whether she was taken from her bed." But there it is straight from Savannah Guthrie herself. That's news. I mean, there was speculation, even we speculated just last week on this program about whether this intruder was possibly knocking on the door before he was like messing with that Nest Cam because it almost looked like a knock. Other people have speculated he rang the doorbell to get Nancy Guthrie to come downstairs um because there didn't appear to be forced entry at least at the front. Uh Ashley Banfield reported early on in this case that her source told her there was forced entry. We don't know which door. She also reported that the back door to the house was left wide open. So presumably it was the back door. But in any event, in her bed is or

from her bed taken in the middle in the dark of night from her bed is new. What if anything does it tell us?

Yeah, good for you. That's why you're an investigative journalist because that's immediately what I picked up on, you know, that okay, this is Wait a minute. Is she just saying that as if to say, you know, sometimes in kidnappings, you know, like a John Manet Ramsay taken, you know, from her bed type of deal. And it's almost like uh, you know, something you would say. But I'm with you. I think she was literally that Savannah knows something that we didn't know and now we do know that she was taken from her bed. Well, that rules out, you know, that uh Miss Guthrie, you know, answered a door, there was a knock on the door, she went out, answered the door, and then the guy took her. Um, that rules that out. If if there was forced entry or any there had to been some type of entry, you know, either forced or she left the door unlocked, god forbid, and and they roused her from her bed. Now, that's a

totally different thing. And so, yeah, that's significant. It also seems to me, will to suggest that Savannah believes her mom did in fact return home to her house after having dinner with Tomaso and Annie, Savannah's sister and brother-in-law earlier in the evening. You know, we've all speculated about whether like what's the proof that Tomaso actually dropped her off at 9:48 with the garage door opening and then closing again at 9:50. Like why do we believe that? Now, we believe the pacemaker continued to work until 2:28 that morning at least, but what's our evidence that Nancy Guthrie was actually in that home. And our only evidence was really that the police said she was, and they seemed to believe it.

And you tell me Savannah saying her mom was taken from her bed seems to tell us that Savannah believes that, too, which means that's what law enforcement told her.

Yeah. I I think that's the only place that she could have drawn that information or getting that information from. And that's not uncommon certainly where family members will be told a little bit of detail, asked to keep it to themselves more often than not. But uh the care management of families in these kinds of situations, whether it be abductions, whether it be kidnappings or or otherwise uh when someone's gone missing, uh will be to try and keep the you know, keep them having a little bit of hope wherever possible. But I I think you know I was speaking with my other panel members with Eric and James uh in the break and I think we're all in the agreements that that this most certainly was an abduction. As to when it exactly happened again we're relying on certain information provided by family members.

Again, how precise they are on their timings again is is potentially questionable and and is very difficult to evidence unless again this is captured on the NES camera and there is evidence of when Nancy actually walked in whether or whether she went in via the garage as it's believed to to be the case. But I think in in terms of this abduction, you know, it is an abduction. If it if it was a kidnap, again, my fellow panel members, we all agree, you know, ultimately they're looking for some sort of ransom. But because of the amount of publicity this has garnished, and I certainly know of many, many cases where someone has been kidnapped by unsophisticated criminals that as soon as it gets some attention, the soon as they believe they're on the radar, it's not a closed affair with family members or whoever they may be demanding the ransom from, then they can panic because of their fear of apprehension. and

dispose of the of the hostage. So I I think regrettably, you know, this was an abduction. If it wasn't for kidnapping, what was the motivation? What was the reasoning behind that?

Eric, what do you think? Well, I'm I'm going to agree, and we did talk about this earlier during the break. It certainly looks like an abduction. We don't know the reasons they were there. It could have been a shakeddown. It could have been some other angry event. And then, of course, the abdu abduction happens and you have a trail of blood leading out of the house. Um, you know, it's interesting that that we have the force entry and that quite possibly the back door is wide open and that she's in the bed. Um, now one thing that I take from Savannah's newest uh video is that the there's more despondency and less hope in the family. Um, she certainly is is starting to come around to the fact that 24 days into it, it's very unlikely that we will ever find Nancy Guthrie alive. I mean, that is heartbreaking. I I think it is now worse for the family that uh they have no way of contacting the

alleged kidnappers and that's why we're saying it's an abduction and that they don't know. And the scary thing here is I think eventually that the the FBI does catch this individual. I mean, it's just an odds game, you know, with enough time it and enough data and enough work, they tend to catch the perpetrator, but do we ever find Nancy? and um and it's it's not likely that we're we're going to find her alive at this point,

right? It's it's been too many days. The other thing that jumped out at me about Savannah's statement was hope against hope. As my sister says, we are blowing on the embers of hope. She mentions the sister, James, which is interesting given all the focus on the sister and more accurately the sister's husband. Um, to me that's a way of endorsing the sister and reminding us they still believe in her and probably in Tomas too. I don't think you mentioned the sister unless you're looking to rehabilitate them both. Um, so I think she communicated something with that too. Your thoughts?

I do and and I think we don't know I don't know enough about their family. She doesn't mention her brother very much but I I would say that that caught my eye but me my ear rather. What I really heard was the million dollars. And I know we talked about this I think two weeks ago when I was with you and the you know the reward was 50 grand and I was was

you said it need to be higher. Yeah. And now here we are you know you said 500,000 right

and and they went up the next day to 100 and now they've gone up there next they're and then they doubled your reward ultimately.

Money talks and for me it it speaks to what I felt the whole time just the lack of urgency in this case. I mean, 24 days, it feels like we're working this like it's a, you know, a robbery or burglary. It just has never felt to me like a human life abduction story. And the cases I've been involved, right, like the case I've been involved in where someone is missing, there is a sense of urgency and you I mean, you're everything you got, you're throwing at it and a $50,000 reward did not seem like urgency. And now here we are 24 days later and okay, a million bucks.

Well, hopefully somebody finally says something, but let's keep going because again, the woman is still out there. Whether she's alive or not, we need to find this lady.

James, that is so true because you, one of the things that was so weird about this case from the get-go was

within 24 hours of realizing Nancy was gone, they called off the search and rescue. The sheriff said, "We're we've called it off." He said, I think permanently, but he said, "But we'll restart it if we need to." The FBI got in and started to deploy resources that I don't know if it was looking for Nancy or looking for clues, but they were looking. But

who ends the search and rescue after 24 hours? Well, you said it. And then he said something else I read this weekend that, you know, he said something like, "We're not giving up." What do you What are you talking about? How do you get that option? You don't get that option. You don't get that I can just give up on finding a a person. That's just not an option for not on the table, right? You're right. And so it's like I mean the sheriff of course is like we're gonna find her. We'll do whatever it takes. Could take days, could take years. What? Right. Like again, who talks like that. But you're right. The lack of of the sense of urgency has been right there in our face all along. And now only now, Will, that that Savannah sounds hopeless. Let's face it. I mean, she's talking about

the sister says we're blowing on the embers of hope. She says she may already be gone. She may already have gone home to the Lord that she loves. She's dancing in heaven with her mom and dad and her beloved brother and with our dad. If this is what is to be, we'll accept it. But we need to know where she is. and then says at the bottom uh we hope help us bring her home our beloved mom so we can either celebrate a glorious miraculous homecoming or she specifically puts us in here celebrate the beautiful brave and courageous noble life that she has lived. So, she's being very explicit here that we recognize she there's a very very good chance that she's dead and it's it's it's hoping against hope that she's not, but now here's a million dollars. So, what's that about?

I know it's bizarre. Um and again this is pure speculation Megan but your point and uh what you were discussing with James just now about the 50,000 which initially came out any opensource research just a simple Google Savannah's uh salary would bring you into into the context of 50,000 is a pittance uh and it doesn't communicate any sense of urgency in terms of wanting to determine or establish um where her mother is. The the other thing is again this is speculation on my part is that certainly the beginning of of communications in the event of it turning into a kidnapping will be to low ball to a certain extent until a figure is actually presented because it gives some sort of indication of what funds may be available or what funds could be readily accessible to resolve or to settle any kind of ransom. Um, so this could have been as a result of poor advice that she was given to only cap it at about 50,000

because I think any uh child uh of a parent that's gone missing is going to offer unbelievable amounts of money to to determine the whereabouts or the safe return of their parent if they've gone missing. So I I think in this instance that

well and there are reports now today that she was reportedly ready. Michael Ruiz of Fox reporting on X. Sources with knowledge of the family's thinking say the Guthri initially raised the idea of the reward, this bigger reward on the first day of the investigation. They were advised by law enforcement to hold off as quote doing so earlier might overwhelm the infrastructure set up to field leads, tens of thousands of which have been coming in organically. They are now offering the seven figure sum after coordinating with investigators. I mean, that makes sense to me. I'm sure Savannah's definitely got tens of millions of dollars in the bank. There's no way she would hesitate to say, "Here's a million to save my mom's life."

Yeah, this is this is poor advice, I think, initially because you want to set a set sense of urgency, but I think even this million dollar sort of reward uh is a mute offer uh because ultimately whoever has been involved in the abduction of Nancy uh is highly unlikely to to provide any kind of evidence unless it's someone associated or a family member or a friend who knows. um the individual or the individuals that are responsible for NY's abduction who are going to furnish that information and ultimately it's a little too much too late.

All right, I'm I'm just going to go cynical reporter for a second here because I I believe that story that Savannah was ready to offer the money from day one and was told by seasoned law enforcement. That's just going to bring every single crazy out of the woodwork who thinks they know anything because a million dollars is a fortune and everyone's going to want it. So, she held it. But there is also I'm just going to say there's also the possibility that the reason somebody close to Savannah talked her out of offering a million dollars early on is they thought somebody might come out of the woodwork and point the finger at them.

You know, I mean it doesn't just because Savannah believes in the sister and the brother-in-law doesn't mean the rest of us have to say they had nothing to do with it. You know, the cops keep going there. They keep searching the place overnight. um they towed her car. And so it's also possible, Eric, that sister Annie or brother-in-law Tomas were quick to push law enforcement's thing, saying that's that's going to cause chaos. Hold that one back. And it would certainly help us understand why only now when they're completely forlorn and they're desperate and feeling and seemingly out of leads did they try to throw some money at the problem.

Yeah, it's it's certainly possible. You know, when I look at this, I wonder, was the sheriff initially thinking this is easily a kidnapping because he saw a a ransom note come in to TMZ, which might be why he releases the crime scene way too early and then sets

but he released it before the ransom note came. He released it and then sets the

Monday and the r the first ransom note I think hit Tuesday evening or Wednesday

and he sets the um well then they the family with law enforcement set the reward way too low. thinking that this is a kidnapping. We're going to work that that chain of investigation and and now realizing that this is not a kidnapping, it's an abdu abduction because kidnappers actually want to make money. They don't um send a note and then never respond to you and give you no avenue to negotiate with them. And here finally, they're looking for those tips. I I like the idea that that you that was raised that, you know, they got 40 50,000 tips and a lot of those tips were nonsense. They were things like, I've got a theory on the case, or you know, I don't like this person, maybe it was them, right? And they have to sift through that. And that's a lot of infrastructure to do that. Um, uh, and then maybe it's fear that if we raise it too much, we're going to invite a lot more of that. But at this point, look,

uh, a million dollars is a lot of money. Somebody knows that guy and may and there's no honor among thieves. Maybe that person, some person will will say, "Hey, I can make a cool billion and and just give up my friend." international disputes, inflation, rising national debt, digital currency. There's a never- ending list of reasons gold has risen over 700% in the last 20 years, and a never- ending list of reasons smart Americans diversify a portion of their savings into precious metals with Birch Gold Group. Gold can thrive during uncertainty, which is why it's a crucial part of a balanced financial strategy. It gives you peace of mind given all the events that could impact the US economy. See if holding gold in a tax sheltered retirement account is right for you. Burge Gold can help you convert an existing IRA or 401k into an IRA in gold. Just text MK to the number 989898 to receive your free info

kit on gold. There's no obligation, just useful information. With an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and tens of thousands of happy customers, consider letting Birch Gold help you diversify with gold so you too can have peace of mind regardless of the uncertainty. Text MK to the number 989898. Thanks so much for watching. If you like what you just saw, hit the subscribe button for more clips and full episodes.

Questions about this episode

Who speaks in "New Savannah Guthrie Video Reveals Nancy Was "Taken From Her Bed" and Ups Reward to $1 Million"?

Savannah Guthrie (Guest), Eric (Guest), James (Guest), Ashley Banfield (Guest).

What is "New Savannah Guthrie Video Reveals Nancy Was "Taken From Her Bed" and Ups Reward to $1 Million" about?

A discussion of Savannah Guthrie’s recent statement claiming Nancy Guthrie was “taken from her bed” in the dark, its potential implications for the case, and how this detail aligns with or contradict earlier reports about possible entry points and the investigation. It also notes speculation about whether the phrase reflects literal kidnapping from bed versus a figurative phrasing used in the…

What is mentioned in this Megyn Kelly episode?

18 people, works and ideas are mentioned, including Nancy Guthrie, Savannah Guthrie, Abduction, reward, Kidnapping, Aurora James. Each one on this page links to its own page with every episode that mentions it.

How long is "New Savannah Guthrie Video Reveals Nancy Was "Taken From Her Bed" and Ups Reward to $1 Million"?

The episode runs 16 min; the transcript is about 3,166 words in 33 timestamped sections.

More from Megyn Kelly

About this transcript: the episode's spoken words as captioned on YouTube, split into timestamped sections. Reclip.Me locates every person, work and idea in the text, keeps the time it is first named, and quotes the words around it verbatim. Last updated February 25, 2026.