Transcript

Are We Supposed to Believe This?

From StevenCrowder · Episode page · Watch on YouTube

· 20 min · 4,122 words · 70 timestamped sections

This is the full, timestamped transcript of "Are We Supposed to Believe This?", an episode of StevenCrowder published January 9, 2026 (20 min, about 4,122 words). It mentions 7 people, works and ideas, including ICE, Jonathan Ross, Rumble, Philadelphia County, Roberto Carlos Munos.

What this episode is about

The discussion centers on a controversial incident involving the shooting of Renee Nicole Good, who was driving an SUV that was stationary for several minutes before the shooting occurred. New video footage has emerged that complicates the narrative, suggesting that Good was part of a group organized to obstruct ICE officers, leading to debates about her intentions and the circumstances surrounding the event.

Key takeaways

  • When it comes to evasive driving, you can't 'just feel like' avoiding the chase; that's how accidents happen.
  • Three minutes of stationary ambiguity: sometimes the question isn't 'why' but 'how long can you stay still?'
  • Pro tip: Moving the goalposts mid-conversation doesn't lend credibility; it just highlights your instability.
  • If escaping the police means running your car over an officer, maybe it's time for a better escape plan.
  • Documenting resistance has its limits—blocking the road for three minutes might just backfire in a police context.

Who speaks in this episode?

What is discussed, and when

  1. – 5:00: ICE
  2. – 10:00: Blackout Coffee, Jonathan Ross, Rumble
  3. – 15:00: Abrego Garcia, Roberto Carlos Munos
  4. – 20:00: Philadelphia County, ICE
  5. – 20:15: Rumble

Notable quotes from "Are We Supposed to Believe This?"

  • Alert, just so if you don't have time to watch all this, this lady trained with a group specifically to impede ICE officers. She was clearly propagandized. She was there with…
    about ICE · at
  • JOSH, how many cups of blackout coffee have you had today?
    about Blackout Coffee · at
  • Attempted to arrest a man who refused to get out of his car. One of the officers, the same man involved in yesterday's shooting, then broke a rear window and reached inside the…
    about Jonathan Ross · at
  • Would it change your mind if I told you that they were specifically on a mission to seek out and to capture Roberto Carlos Munos Guatemala, an illegal from Mexico and child sex offender.
    about Roberto Carlos Munos · at
  • Marilyn man, was it Brego Garcia?
    about Abrego Garcia · at
  • Over American ICE agents. Okay, let's be clear about that. Here's the Philadelphia sheriff vowing to go to war with ICE over his love for violent gang members and child…
    about Philadelphia County · at
  • YouTube. You've probably noticed something is missing by now. I'm not here. That's because The Live Daily Show is now streaming exclusively on Rumble weekdays at 11:00 a.m. Eastern. Tune in there where nothing is censored.
    about Rumble · at

Who and what is mentioned in this episode?

People

  • Jonathan Ross — Person · Referenced ICE agent (named individual) · 2 mentions · first at
    Identified as the ICE agent involved in the shooting and previously dragged by a car, used to argue heightened threat perception and justification.
  • Roberto Carlos Munos — Person · Referenced alleged target (criminal suspect) · 1 mention · first at
    Cited as an example of the type of person ICE allegedly seeks (child sex offender), supporting the argument that opposition to ICE protects dangerous criminals.
  • Abrego Garcia — Person · Referenced example (alleged trafficker) · 1 mention · first at
    Used rhetorically as another example of a purportedly serious criminal that the speakers claim activists would still defend against ICE.

Companies & orgs

  • ICE — Company · Core organization in controversy · 2 mentions · first at
    ICE is the focal institution in the episode’s dispute: agents are portrayed as enforcing law against violent criminals while being obstructed and delegitimized by activists and local officials.
  • Rumble — Company · Recommended platform / distribution channel · 3 mentions · first at
    Promoted as an alternative to YouTube due to alleged censorship; the show claims to stream exclusively on Rumble.

Places & events

  • Philadelphia County — Place · Referenced political/jurisdictional setting · 2 mentions · first at
    Mentioned as the jurisdiction of a sheriff/official who vows to oppose ICE, illustrating institutional resistance to federal immigration enforcement.

Sponsors

  • Blackout Coffee — Company · Advertised sponsor/product · 3 mentions · first at
    Appears in an ad read with promo code and product plug, indicating monetization and sponsorship within the episode.

Full transcript with timestamps

Now, as the vehicle passes, you can see the dark colored SUV driven by Renee Nicole Good. Now, prior to this, the video shows the SUV had been stationary and sideways across the road like that for about 3 minutes. The reason for that is unclear.

Unclear. Oh, okay. I see it. You've moved the goalposts again. Speaking of being an adult, don't run over officers.

Pro tip anymore? No, ever. Oh, yeah. Ever. I just feel like I have to reinforce it.

Yeah. So, uh, the ICE shooting, getting back to, uh, the domestic issue, the goalposts just keep moving. They keep moving at, uh, light speed. And yesterday, CNN, we have a few updates here, but, CNN released a new angle that I would say clears up a lot. Spoiler alert, just so you know, if you don't have time to watch all this, this lady trained with a group specifically to impede ICE officers. She was clearly propagandized. She was there with purpose and she was there blocking the street for at least in this one instance following many instances throughout the day. 3 minutes the new video which is giving us a clearer picture of what happened in the moments leading up to the fatal encounter. A warning it is disturbing. Now as the vehicle passes you can see the dark colored SUV driven by Renee Nicole Good. That's on the right there in the back. Uh the surveillance video taken by a home nearby. Agents can be seen milling about

near the vehicle, then converging on it. And then you see right there, the SUV begins to move, and that's when the shots are fired. Now, prior to this, the video shows the SUV had been stationary and sideways across the road like that for about 3 minutes. The reason for that is unclear.

Yes. Un unclear. Oh, okay. I see it. You've moved the goalposts again. I It's unclear. Not only was it clear uh two days ago that it was murder, not only was it clear that this was a completely innocent person, but it was really clear. Back to your goalpost. This was just a lady trying to flee.

We've seen what happened uh to this woman for I believe it was just a few blocks away from where George Floyd was murdered. And what we need to see is is this incident prosecuted. What we saw today was a criminal a criminal murder a woman and shoot her in the head uh while she was trying to escape and flee for her life.

She was trying to escape and flee for her life. Okay. Hey, she was there for 3 minutes. Well, I guess IT'S UNCLEAR. YOU SAID ESCAPING and fleeing. We're not gonna let you move those goalposts, sweetheart. And by the way, that's just a proxy for the left at large. That's what they were all saying.

Yeah. By the way, one of the major critiques, and this video actually dispels it, and I don't think a lot of people are talking about this. If you go back and play the end, the the end of that video or the beginning, I guess, of the CNN clip there where the officer is talking to the passenger that was filming, it looks like that was the passenger that got out. He walks back to his vehicle and then proceeds to walk around the front of her car. Good's car. Doesn't look like he stops to stand there until she starts to move and then he freezes.

Right. And that's what Yeah, because that's what we previously thought. I've seen people like, "Oh, you don't stand in front of the car." Right.

Yeah, I've seen that. Oh, a police regulate. You don't That's not what you do. Walking up, she moves. She freezes

and then she pulls into him like he looks like he's walking around to the front of her car and then to the side where she's driving.

And now, do we know this? No. But let me just ask you this. Let's say you're walking around the front, I don't know, park, let's say parking lot. You know, you do this probably 10 times a day and don't realize it. You're walking in front of a car. All right. You're walking and then you hear It's probably what you do, right?

Everybody on Earth does that. He's assessing, okay, what do I need to do to get out of danger here? Like that that was one of the critiques. And I'm like, look, this guy, he's not also none of these guys are running. None of these guys are doing things that are like super uber threatening. Get out of the car. That's different. Stop. That's different. They're not like, "We're going to kill you. You're running for your life from police and this guy's like casually walking through the front and then all of a sudden, oh crap."

Yeah. Like and if you go with that narrative using your point there that stop or exit the vehicle warrants fearing for your life then everyone can justify those actions at every single traffic stop.

Anytime someone tells you to an officer tells you to get out of your vehicle you can just hit him with your car.

Mhm. You can or or stupid you can flee. I remember being in Austin. I think I was n I was 18 at the time and I remember a guy being tased by the cops. Turns out he had left the bar. he'd been drunk and I guess he had hit beaten up a few people including a woman and I didn't know at the time. I found out afterward but I just he and I see this commotion. I remember walking up and a police officer saying sir stop please move back. I went oh okay

that's it. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. I was drunk in Oklahoma City and I I wanted to fight a guy in a bar and I was waiting for him outside like a real I look like an idiot. I was pacing. I was all mad and the guy came outside started yelling at him. THE COP WAS LIKE GO GET OUT OF HERE. GO HOME. AND I WAS LIKE, "All right,

yeah, fine. You suck, but all right. All right, pig fight cops who are sober." Yeah. Okay.

I said, "I'm going to go for a dig." Also, by the way, uh it's confirmed now. Uh this cop was dragged by the car, just in case people were wondering. So, we have some new confirmed details.

The six months ago thing. Yeah. Yeah. Renee, good. She was part of a group that worked to quote document and resist immigration officers in Minneapolis. the child she was raising with her lesbian lover uh actually attended the Southside Family Charter School. Here's a school's mission statement. The Southside Family Charter School is a small K5 school that meets the needs of a culturally and ethnically diverse population by engaging children in critical thinking and problem solving involving children in political and social activism, encouraging creative expression, including with vehicles, offering a wide range of electives, and advocating for children and families.

Yes. A wide range of electives, including, by the way, track and field. Yeah. Oh, cool.

We couldn't show the javelin. How do they teach the kindergarters how to read? Make protest signs.

Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Well, let's be honest, they they can't. Um, really quickly, best way to stand download the Rumble app cuz this is one of those scenarios. I remember this with George Floyd and co there's going to be censorship that you're not going to see. There's going to be censorship on YouTube that you're not going to be you're not going to be able to find what it is that you're looking for. That's how they control it. What's much more concerning and pervasive is the soft censorship where you search for something and it doesn't show up. It's not a policy to ban it. So download the Rumble app, follow us there. You'll never be out of touch.

What the heck is that? These are scripts I wrote today for you to approve. Those are all scripts.

Yeah. Well, I mean, technically some of them are songs, but uh I got a lot of really cool stuff in here. Got some ABBA parodies in here. I know you love ABA. Big Aba guy. Everyone always talks about you love ABA.

And you wrote THEM ALL TODAY. THAT'S WHAT I SAID. HOW IN THE WORLD were you able to write all OF THOSE IN FAST, GERALD? REAL FAST.

JOSH, how many cups of blackout coffee have you had today? How many cups of this guy? Can you believe that? HOW MANY CUPS? I DON'T KNOW. HOW MANY CUPS OF COFFEE? HOW MANY PIECES OF BEAR IN THE WOODS, GERALD?

I HAVE no idea how I would even know that. Oh, yeah. You wouldn't know that, would you? I forgot. You wouldn't know that. You got no experience. I know that. You know why I KNOW THAT? CUZ I'VE SEEN THINGS, MAN. All the things I've seen.

My leg. Josh. Josh. Josh. Listen. No more blackout coffee today. You're done. Okay. Tomorrow. Coffee today. No more coffee. No. No. No.

Josh. Zero more cups of Josh. Get out of my office. No more cups of coffee. Go.

Go. All right. Whatever you say, boss. Okay. Fire. Josh. Go to blackout coffee.com/crowder. Use the promo code crowder for 20% off your first order and try the new exclusive strange animal brew. Yes, I chose the beans. It is the blend that we drink here exclusively and now I'm making it available to you. According to the mother from the school, uh she said she was a warrior. She died doing what was right, running over officers. Renee Good was trained against these ICE agents. What to do, what not to do. It's a very thorough training.

Against? Well, I guess she slept through class. To listen to commands, to know your rights, to whistle when you see an ICE agent. Oh, well, that's not a very clear communication. I just I would look for an attractive lady.

Oh, that was the problem. Or is it Jessica Rabbit? She dropped her whistle on the accelerator.

A It's a very large whistle. Jeez. It's a commercial grade whistle. The police officer.

It's a machine, not an appliance at that point. The ICE agent, as we know, Jonathan Ross, uh, it is confirmed. We ran this yesterday, but we said we Gnome had specified this, but we said we we don't know if that report is specifically of that officer. It's now confirmed. Does this matter? Remember the left I said, "Well, you should change you should change your mind. You should be open to new information." Does this information maybe shed some light on it? Maybe you should be a little gracious to someone who still needs to go home to their family. This was the ICE officer who was dragged within an inch of his life.

Back in June, ICE agents in Minneapolis attempted to arrest a man who refused to get out of his car. One of the officers, the same man involved in yesterday's shooting, then broke a rear window and reached inside the car to unlock the door. The driver accelerated, dragging the officer about 100 yards. So, as you can see in this picture, the incident left the ICE officer with injuries. The officer fired his taser at the driver, but was unsuccessful in stopping him. He was freed when the car knocked him out of the window.

So, let me ask you this. If you had been dragged by a car uh and had 30 something stitches and you had to go home to your spouse or family and say, "Man, I I just I missed it by that much. I could just as easily not be here today." And you found yourself in the exact same situation again. You think you'd be on alert? And and if we're going to talk about extending grace to people who have PTSD from someone using a naughty word, would would would we extend, hey, not only this person didn't do anything wrong, but some understanding to someone who wants to still go home to his family, which by the way is part of their duty.

If none of that, if you say, "No, no, I don't care that he was dragged. I don't care that she was there for 3 minutes. I don't care that she was trained specifically to do this and was looking for it. I don't care about any of that because still at the core of this is these the ends justify the means because they were protecting people. These ICE agents are tearing apart families. Okay. Would it change your mind if I told you that they were specifically on a mission to seek out and to capture Roberto Carlos Munos Guatemala, an illegal from Mexico and child sex offender.

Maybe it was just me too. domestic assault. That's who this woman ran over a cop for. Sorry. Officer,

I believe that. Is that the 200? I'm sorry. That's the case from June where he was dragged. I think that may be

Oh, is that the case in Is it not this? They had a mission this time. I thought

they had a mission this time. We don't know. I don't think we know who this is. Same scenario. He was He was trying to get that person, right, and gets dragged by car. He goes in front of another car. He knows exactly what could happen now.

This guy was the one for Oh, sorry. That's right. Yes. Sorry, I mixed up the order. So that was why he was dragged.

Yeah. Uh then this time he was going after a I can never say trend aua. No, this is something.

This is Oregon. Yeah. Different in Portland. This isn't hockey. Here's the thing. Here's the thing. Every single one of these things. Who do you think they're going after? They're going after a guy that's like got a hot dog stand down.

This is a very specific mission with a violent hardened criminal. That's what he was doing last time. That's what was going on now. We don't know who it was specifically this time. My guess is that they didn't apprehend the person super effectively because they were being run over with cars. And then

and and here's look and and I apologize. I got my my order there mixed up. That is you can admonish me. I definitely deserve that one.

Oh, admonish Cheryl. No, admonish me. Oh, no. Not me. Both of us. Why both? No, no, no, no, no.

Yeah, both. Because the captain goes down with the ship, you know, every time. Remember how I how I told you that uh it wasn't about anchor babies when we were talking about immigration? What about the ch because the left wouldn't deport violent criminals who are in our prisons. Remember that? I said, well, yeah, but you won't deport criminals in our prisons who shouldn't be here. It's the same thing here. They go, these are families. You'd still do it anyway. Let me tell you why. Free Maduro. You'd run over officers to protect Maduro.

Okay. Marilyn man, was it Brego Garcia? Was very likely was a human trafficker. I believe that that was finally confirmed. It was suspected and confirmed. So, let's stop with this. We're just protecting innocent people. If these leftists knew that it was a Maduro or knew that it was a Garcia, the Carlos Brown Jr., take your pick of the worst. They would do it anyway. It's because they hate you. It's because they hate this country. It's because they hate the idea of borders. It's because they hate the idea of law and order. It's because they hate anything that President Trump does and they hate anything that you stand for. Just to be clear. No. No. It's just because it's families. Okay. But let me ask you this.

Would you not show up and block ICE officers if you knew they were child sex offenders? If you knew that they were human traffickers? If you knew that they were totalitarian dictators? No. You would. Free Maduro. I'm done acting like we're going to have this conversation on an honest playing field.

Mhm. Because in Oregon, that's the other one. There was the uh the Venezuelan uh trend, however you say it. Aragua. Aragua. That's right. Otherwise, it's just trend of water.

It's trendy. Trendiagua. Yeah. It's like Evian. Okay. It's not. So, there was uh they were going after uh meaning patrol agents were going after someone there was a member of that gang. And uh you had agents who were uh harmed, who were assaulted while they were going after hardened criminals. I believe, by the way, there was also a video of that of uh the officers being assaulted. Let's just let's just call this what it is. Let's stop acting like none of this is justifiable. And the left doesn't care if these are innocent people who overstate a visa or a child rapist or Maduro. They will still side with them over American ICE agents. Okay, let's be clear about that. Here's the Philadelphia sheriff vowing to go to war with ICE over his love for violent gang members and child traffickers. Let know that law enforcement professionals, real ones, not the fake madeup ICE, probably Trump's uh new army to attack citizens

of the United States. So, we stand here today with all those who stand against the madeup fake what you can call ICE uh professional law enforcement. I don't call them none of that. I call them madeup fake want to be law enforcement.

That's a long name because what they do is against not only legal law but the moral law. If any of them want to come in this city and commit a crime, you will not be able to hide. Nobody will wish you off. You don't want this smoke

cuz we will bring it. Go back to the CORNER CUZ I SMOKE CRAP. That's Philadelphia County, I believe. So, she said and she started off by saying this woman's name. Say her name. Say her name. See, I think they said it three times. I don't know if they're trying to conjure her or what, but you know, figure it out.

Chance. That's like can't even just say dumb in the mirror. Exactly. And then it happens. And then she goes on to say that, you know, these are fake law enforcement. we will arrest them and then we will and she's basically saying like you won't be able to be whisked away basically so your identity is protected. That's exactly what they're saying, right? We will arrest you. We will remove your masks and we will let everybody know who these ICE agents are. And then you've got morons out there saying, "I can't believe we have people in masks running around. Why do they have to have masks?"

I wonder. Yeah, it's because law enforcement officers are out there doing their jobs and people are starting to hunt them because of that. That's why. Because the left is a bunch of radicals saying, "Ah, this is just Trump's hitman going out."

I don't even think that's it with the police with these police forces. I think some, you know, maybe not all of them, sure, but I think some of these police forces have a uh a great reason to do this. They uh they want the heat off of them.

Yeah. They're like, "Oh, the people they they've been protesting and burning our cities down because of the crap that we did. Uh

go after ICE. We're the good guys now." Yeah. Hey, look, we're on your side. We're the we're the cops. We're the good guys.

We are going to go to war. We're going to fight you. We're going to Great. Now do MS-13. Neither do the people in your city.

If you could please also mind. This is this is not something empirical, but I will tell you this. You can go back to a change my mind where we were I think it was a build the wall and there was a a lady. We had to blur her face because she was a Hispanic lady and she had a bunch of illegal aliens in her neighborhood and these criminals basically ran the neighborhood and she didn't know what she could do about it because she was afraid. She lived under threat. That happens a lot. I can tell you this. I pretty much never spend time on social, but I was looking at some yesterday and I noticed a huge portion of my new followers are uh Venezuelan are people from Latin American countries. There's been a notable uptick in the percentage

where they are glad to see some Americans change. Thank God. Yeah. So, they're not doing the tribalism like, "Hey, we're all Hispanic."

They are tired of it. These are the people who have to live with it. You know who you didn't see interviewed

uh in Aurora? I believe it was Colorado. Yeah. All the other Hispanic people there who lived under the tyrannical rule of gang violence.

They probably wouldn't have either out of fear, right? You don't see them. So you think so the left the the privileged leftists think that they're standing up for these people, but instead it's just like the people here with Iran. Well, the I don't think that we should Why would we want to bomb Iran? When they say that they mean uh nuclear refinement facilities with pretty much zero collateral damage. Why would we want to do that? Well, I don't know. Because the people don't want to be killed in the streets. Oh. Oh, you're siding with the government. Well, why why would we want to deport brown people? Well, I don't know. Because the brown people who are here legally are tired of having their lives and their families threatened if they don't play ball under the table.

Maybe that. Who Who do you side with? They're not the same. Illegal aliens are not the same as legal immigrants. Both have problems, by the way. But in these towns, the gang members are not the same as the people who are not members of the gangs. You do have to pick a side. Who do you want to support? Because someone's going to come out on top. The people of Iran are not the same as the government of Iran. You do have to pick a side because someone's going to come out on top and that's who you have to live with. Okay? If there was a war going on in the house next door to where you live, two people, okay? One of them is going to be in that house. One's a gang member, one's a law-abiding citizen.

Doing nothing isn't the moral decision at that point. The war is already going on. So, you are picking aside through inaction. And in this case, the left has chosen proactive action to protect, defend, and and venerate violent criminals. Oh, you're still here. And you're still watching this on YouTube. You've probably noticed something is missing by now. I'm not here. That's because The Live Daily Show is now streaming exclusively on Rumble weekdays at 11:00 a.m. Eastern. Tune in there where nothing is censored.

Questions about this episode

Who speaks in "Are We Supposed to Believe This?"?

Steven Crowder (Host), Renee Nicole Good (Guest), Josh (Guest), Gerald (Guest).

What is "Are We Supposed to Believe This?" about?

The discussion centers on a controversial incident involving the shooting of Renee Nicole Good, who was driving an SUV that was stationary for several minutes before the shooting occurred. New video footage has emerged that complicates the narrative, suggesting that Good was part of a group organized to obstruct ICE officers, leading to debates about her intentions and the circumstances…

What is mentioned in this StevenCrowder episode?

7 people, works and ideas are mentioned, including ICE, Jonathan Ross, Rumble, Philadelphia County, Roberto Carlos Munos, Abrego Garcia. Each one on this page links to its own page with every episode that mentions it.

How long is "Are We Supposed to Believe This?"?

The episode runs 20 min; the transcript is about 4,122 words in 70 timestamped sections.

More from StevenCrowder

About this transcript: the episode's spoken words as captioned on YouTube, split into timestamped sections. Reclip.Me locates every person, work and idea in the text, keeps the time it is first named, and quotes the words around it verbatim. Last updated January 24, 2026.